Weekly Market Report - May 19, 2026
- 3 days ago
- 7 min read
***
Manhattan’s top office developers, including BXP’s Hilary Spann, express frustration over market indifference despite strong performance. BXP owns the fully-occupied GM Building and is constructing a 1 million-square-foot tower, with 94% of its New York space leased. However, its stock has decreased by 13% in the past year. Vornado Realty Trust also faces a similar situation despite plans for a $6 billion tower and recent property acquisitions. At the Sohn Investment Conference, concerns about AI's impact on office space emerged, though some maintain optimism about the Manhattan market's appeal.
***
The Penn Station neighborhood, known for dirty streets and claustrophobic train station, attracting blue-chip office tenants
Manhattan’s Penn Station area, once deemed a "hellhole," is transforming into a thriving office market, attracting tenants like Major League Soccer and Dick’s Sporting Goods. Rising occupancy rates and rents signal the area's potential, especially with a wave of new developments led by Vornado Realty Trust, which enhanced its towers with amenities such as a fitness center and rooftop park. The region captures nearly 25% of city office relocations anticipated between 2023 and 2025. While federal plans to revamp the aging station could ignite further interest, skepticism persists due to past failures. However, new leadership and potential funding raise optimism. Vornado’s $1.2 billion redevelopment gamble is reaping rewards, driving demand. Economic uncertainty and potential AI-driven job losses pose challenges, but significant revitalization efforts are underway, promising enduring changes to the area's appeal and value.
***
A Texas developer, Thakkar Developers, who bought the Midtown office tower at 135 W. 50th St. for $8.5 million—97% less than the previous owner UBS paid 20 years ago—faces the potential loss of the building due to an alleged default on $28 million in property tax bills. The 23-story structure was only 35% occupied during the sale and Thakkar had proposed a partial conversion into apartments. However, Safehold, a real estate investment trust and ground lease owner, has filed a lawsuit to seize the building, demanding Thakkar vacate the premises.
Safehold had previously issued a notice of default in May 2025 and granted extensions to Thakkar. The company, led by CEO Jay Sugarman, holds land under several Manhattan buildings and reported $115 million in net income last year. Thakkar Developers is notably based in Texas and this acquisition appears to be its first project in New York with a focus on Texas developments previously.
***
Mortgage backing 979 Third Ave transferred to special servicing
Charles Cohen’s company faces challenges at 979 Third Avenue as their $150 million loan on the Decoration & Design Building entered special servicing due to its May 6 maturity, resulting in a default. Green Loan Services has been assigned as the special servicer. Originally a $165 million loan from Citigroup in 2015, it was affected by bond downgrades last year; however, it remained current last month. Cohen’s general counsel claimed they are collaborating with the lender and plan to refinance soon. The building’s occupancy dropped from 95% in 2015 to 63% last year, with annual revenue falling to $36.7 million from $48.4 million in the past decade. Compounding issues arise as Cohen does not own the underlying land, leading to rising lease payments.
***
Deal locks in biggest piece of massive Midtown assemblage
Gary Barnett's Extell Development acquired the site at 405-417 Park Avenue for $500 million, bolstering his extensive Midtown holdings. The deal included $20 million spent on air rights from Central Synagogue, with Barnett potentially pursuing two adjacent properties for expansion. The acquired sites, covering a full blockfront between East 54th and 55th streets, were sold by Corem Property Group AB and DWS. The assemblage allows for development of about 527,000 square feet, expandable to 700,000 square feet with additional air rights. Barnett is also negotiating for 110 East 55th Street, with tenants advised to vacate. Furthermore, he aims to purchase 111 East 54th Street, home to The Brook. Located near major corporate headquarters, Barnett’s acquisition positions him for future high-end office or mixed-use developments.
***
Brookfield and the Qatar Investment Authority (QIA) are set to gain nearly $300 million by refinancing 2 Manhattan West, a newly constructed Midtown office tower. This significant payout highlights the lucrative opportunities in New York’s commercial real estate, particularly for new properties, while older buildings struggle to recover from pandemic-related tenant losses. The refinancing, led by a Wells Fargo-led banking group, involves a $1.9 billion mortgage, generating a cash return of $273 million for Brookfield and QIA. Occupying 97% of its space, 2 Manhattan West features firms like Cravath and KPMG, with average gross rents of $132 per square foot. This contrasts sharply with the challenges facing other office towers in Manhattan, where vacancy rates reach 20%.
***
Mall owners resort to banning anyone under 18 unaccompanied by adult, following waves of teen disruptions at their properties
Darcel Clark witnessed disruptive behavior from a group of teenagers at the Mall at Bay Plaza, leading to the arrest of 18 individuals. In response to increasing disturbances, mall owners are instituting bans on unaccompanied minors under 18. These policies, often enforcing adult chaperones, aim to combat violence, gang issues, and shoplifting. While mall operators assert these measures enhance safety without significantly hurting sales, some teenagers feel marginalized and argue against penalizing all for the actions of a few.
Despite restrictions, malls seek to attract Generation Z, recognizing their significant spending power. Some policies are enforced only during high-traffic periods, while security checks vary by location. Instances of teen chaos have prompted malls like GGP to adopt stricter chaperone requirements. Although affected teens like Jasmine Hedrick initially resented these policies, she has grown to appreciate the resulting reduction in disorder.
***
The Taystee Lab Building in Harlem, a $700 million life sciences project completed four years ago, faces foreclosure as it remains entirely vacant. Wells Fargo claims owner Janus Property defaulted on a $50 million mortgage, now totaling $51.4 million with fees. The building has no tenants, and the life sciences sector in New York appears stagnant, with a 35% availability rate. Interest in lab space has cooled, attributed to reduced venture capital for startups. Initially envisioned as a hub for various businesses, Taystee Lab has shifted focus to life sciences after multiple past project proposals failed. The current legal dispute arose from a refinance loan Wells Fargo issued in 2022, which Janus failed to repay on time.
***
Léman Manhattan Preparatory School successfully achieved a 27.5% rent reduction for its leased space at 25 Broadway after refusing to pay rent for over a year. This resulted in a decrease of its annual rent from $6.3 million to $4.7 million, as reported by credit-rating agency KBRA. The school, which serves 700 students from kindergarten through high school, pays $98,000 annually for tuition, room, and board. Established in 2005 and purchased by a private-equity group in 2011, Léman faced lease default from June 2023 with landlord Wolfson Group.
A restructured lease agreement effective until 2030 includes a 27.5% rent reduction through November 2026 and gradual annual increases thereafter. A significant investment of $40 million from Collegio Partners in 2025 eliminated the school's debt, including back rent owed. This situation illustrates the advantageous position of tenants amid high vacancy rates in the Financial District, where Léman is a major tenant.
***
Vornado Realty Trust plans to introduce outdoor seating areas adjacent to three restaurants in a passageway off West 34th Street near Penn Station. This developer, controlling much of the area, aims to create a more inviting atmosphere in a space previously known for illegal activities. The proposal, submitted to the Department of City Planning, suggests using about 20% of the 8,000-square-foot passageway for approximately 90 tables. Specific restaurants benefiting from the seating have not been disclosed, but existing tenants include Roberta’s pizzeria and Anita Gelato. Approval from the Planning department is necessary as the proposal involves allocating public space to for-profit businesses, adhering to zoning regulations established during the complex's development in the 1970s. Other nearby eateries already feature outdoor seating.
***
Investment advisory firm Institutional Shareholders Services (ISS) criticized SL Green's executive pay, urging shareholders to vote against it at the upcoming annual meeting. Despite acknowledging some improvements in CEO Marc Holliday's nearly $17 million pay package, ISS objected to new excessive severance benefits for executives. This ongoing conflict over executive compensation has spanned a decade, with ISS consistently opposing SL Green’s pay practices. Although SL Green claims to have made changes in response to shareholder feedback, ISS asserts these adjustments are inadequate, particularly regarding benefits for certain executives. Despite some support for SL Green's directors, ISS views the company's actions as insufficient.
***
A pair of mixed-use buildings in Manhattan's Theater District has been sold for the first time in over 20 years. Purchased by Dublin-born brothers Michael and Patrick McNamee of PMac’s Hospitality Group for $7.5 million, the properties at 140-142 West 46th St. expand their Manhattan portfolio, which includes popular venues. The 12,675-square-foot site contains two five-story buildings, housing a vacant restaurant space previously home to Prime Catch, six market-rate apartments, and five rent-stabilized apartments. The seller, Bekim-Ferit Corp., listed the buildings in August 2024 for $12 million; they sold for 37.5% less. The McNamee brothers plan to open a new restaurant, but further details remain unconfirmed.
***
White-shoe law firm will pay at least $150 psf
Property & Building Corp. has secured a 122,000-square-foot lease at 10 Bryant with Baker McKenzie, indicating the building’s recovery following HSBC's departure in 2024. The law firm is expanding to occupy approximately 15 percent of the building, totaling seven and a half floors. Baker McKenzie will pay around $150 per square foot, significantly higher than Midtown’s average of $90.36. The firm opted to stay at 10 Bryant over relocating to 343 Madison Avenue. JLL facilitated the leasing. This moves the building closer to full occupancy after earlier leases with Amazon and Life Time. 10 Bryant includes a 30-story tower and a connected 10-story building, reflecting Manhattan's office market resurgence amid tightening supply. PBC plans to invest $43 million in modernization efforts.
***
A 103,000-square-foot office building at 261-267 Canal St. in SoHo has been sold for $36 million to a consortium including Jeremy Aidan, Ebi Khalili, Josh Rahmani, Adam Rubin, and Andrew Shanfeld. Developer Philip Chong previously operated Canal Street Market at the site before closing it in December 2024. The building, historically home to Studebaker Brothers Manufacturing Company in the 1890s, currently has around 50% occupancy with short-term tenants. Meridian Capital Group’s Chirag Doshi represented the buyers and lender, Shanghai Commercial Bank. While future plans for the property are unclear, Doshi believes the buyers' developments could rejuvenate the block, currently troubled by street vendors.
Comments